What's the Context? To begin, let's frame the question in which we are exploring these ways of thinking. What is the nature of mathematics? Is it something that exists regardless of human existence (discovered), or is it something which humans formulated (invented)? This is a question that has been tossed around for centuries (if you couldn't tell by the name of Platonism), and there still isn't one widely accepted answer. The goal here is to present two of the most prevalent fields of thought, my current thinking, and short-comings of all three. Allegory of the Cave One of the more well known thought experiments is Plato's Allegory of the Cave. In this particular conceptualization, there is a group of prisoners which are restrained such that the only interaction they have with the outside world is to see a flat 2D shadow of the things that lie behind them. Plato considered mathematics to be no different than this. He believed there to be a "realm of...